tools for document interoperability

 
privacy 
 
 
attribution 
 

This is the web diary for nfoWorks and realization of the Harmony Principles. Pursuing Harmony tracks nfoWorks research, analysis, specification, and implementation of tools for document interoperability. There is commentary on related activities that address conformance, interoperability, and harmonization of document formats.



Click for Blog Feed
Blog Feed

Recent Items
 
Let’s Try This for a While
 
Hooptedoodle: Blog Aversion and Standards Ignoranc...
 
ODF Implementation-Support Toolkits and Libraries
 
Adding Pursuing Harmony to Technorati
 
Office Shots for Confirmed ODF Interchange Fidelit...
 
ODF Interoperability at The Hague
 
ODF and IPR/Licensing Concerns
 
Open Government Data: Simple Principles
 
2009-03-25: Document Freedom Day
 
Retiring InfoNuovo.com

This page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours?

Locations of visitors to nfoWorks

The nfoCentrale Blog Conclave
 
Millennia Antica: The Kiln Sitter's Diary
 
nfoWorks: Pursuing Harmony
 
Numbering Peano
 
Orcmid's Lair
 
Orcmid's Live Hideout
 
Prof. von Clueless in the Blunder Dome
 
Spanner Wingnut's Muddleware Lab (experimental)

nfoCentrale Associated Sites
 
DMA: The Document Management Alliance
 
DMware: Document Management Interoperability Exchange
 
Millennia Antica Pottery
 
The Miser Project
 
nfoCentrale: the Anchor Site
 
nfoWare: Information Processing Technology
 
nfoWorks: Tools for Document Interoperability
 
NuovoDoc: Design for Document System Interoperability
 
ODMA Interoperability Exchange
 
Orcmid's Lair
 
TROST: Open-System Trustworthiness

2010-04-15

 

The Real Challenge of Achieving and Sustaining Interoperability

I recently encountered a new blog by Moritz Berger of Microsoft.  Moritz’s first two posts reveal the among amount of goo and disruption there is beneath the surface of any attempt to collaborate when using standard office-productivity formats among different desktop software products.

I take Moritz’s posts as anecdotal demonstrations of the challenges that we face in attempting interchange and collaboration on documents using different products that claim support of the same standard.  What we expect to be matter-of-fact and effortless is simply not so.  The thornier problems of converting among formats place easy-going collaboration even farther out of reach. 

In that spirit, I recommend Moritz’s latest offering: How To Enhance (Or Destroy) Collaboration.

I am not advocating abandonment of open standards development.  But it is easy to see how there is a natural tendency for communities of adopters to settle on specific products that they all agree to use in order to avoid pitfalls and surprises beyond their control.

If the promise of product substitution and effective multi-platform support is to be made real, we have to become much better at knowing what it means when a product supports a format, how that support changes with new releases, and how this all sorts out when we throw different product implementations into the mix.  We also need some way of actually knowing and safeguarding against use of product functionalities for which interoperability with other productions/versions is at best haphazard when not simply hopeless.

It looks like an uphill struggle.  We must do better.

 
Construction Structure (Hard Hat Area)
Creative Commons License You are navigating nfoWorks.
This work is licensed under a
Creative Commons Attribution 2.5 License.

template created 2008-08-13-18:06 -0700 (pdt)
$$Author: Orcmid $
$$Date: 13-11-11 20:08 $
$$Revision: 1 $